The Best Ice Cube Trays of 2024, Tested and Reviewed

Oct 14, 2024

When you buy through our links, Business Insider may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more

While most ice cube trays successfully freeze water, they can be difficult to maneuver when full, don't release the ice easily, take up too much space in the freezer, or produce misshapen cubes. To solve those problems, classic plastic trays are being replaced by silicone molds and trays with locking lids.

I conducted multiple rounds of testing on the 16 best ice cube trays and molds and spoke with Gitter and Micah Melton, Beverage Director at The Aviary, to find out what makes a great ice cube tray. My top pick is the W&P Everyday Ice Cube Tray, and it still is after years of use. It has the smoothest release, and one trip through the dishwasher makes it look and smell like new. For drinks on the rocks or anything that needs to stay as pure as possible, the Tovolo Sphere Ice Molds produce spherical ice with smooth ridges and without leaking.

Whether you're a cocktail aficionado or just a fan of iced water, one of the best ice cube trays in this guide is perfect for you.

Best overall: W&P Everyday Ice Cube Tray - See at Amazon

Best for spheres: Tovolo Sphere Ice Molds (2-pack) - See at Amazon

Best for large cubes: Samuelworld Large Ice Cube Tray - See at Amazon

Best spill-proof: OXO Good Grips No-Spill Ice Cube Tray - See at Amazon

The W&P Everyday Tray had the smoothest release of all the trays we tested; each cube popped out without any resistance.

Specifics

The construction of the Everyday Tray is unique among the ice cube trays I tested, and is one of the big reasons why this is the best ice cube tray I tested. The Everyday Tray is made of silicone and none of the cubes share a wall, so you can release them one at a time by applying pressure to the bottom. I also found that this helps the cubes release easily because there is no friction between neighboring ice cubes and the whole tray doesn't empty out at once.

Like many silicone trays, the Everyday Tray wobbled slightly when I walked it to the freezer, but the reinforced rim provides a good grip. The lid doesn't seal, though it allows for stacking and promises some protection from odors. After using it for multiple years, I did notice a silicone smell coming from the tray. Luckily, it's dishwasher safe, and one load later, my tray was as good as new.

Another great option is the Tovolo Perfect Cube Ice Tray. The Tovolo's unified bottom and plastic lid make it easy to store. It does make three more cubes than the Everyday Tray, but the cubes are much harder to get out. Though this tray has a sealing lid, it leaks more than our favorite no-spill tray, so it just gives you stacking ability.

The Tovolo Sphere Molds’ silicone and plastic construction makes them easy to fill and store without spills.

Specifics

I tested three sphere molds and overflowed all of them, except for the Tovolo. The Tovolo has a plastic bottom with a marked max fill line and a silicone top. You fill the bottom portion and then push in the top, which squeezes out any excess water. There is no space for overflow to sneak in and freeze an odd shape to the sphere.

After freezing, the instructions recommended running the plastic section under hot water, and I found the spheres popped out easily after doing so. All of the spheres had slight ridges where the top and bottom of the mold meet, but this line was less noticeable than on spheres made using other molds.

I also liked the Peak Sphere Ice Tray. This tray is made entirely of silicone, unlike the other spherical trays, which included at least some plastic. The silicone construction means these spheres were the easiest to get out of the mold right out of the freezer. Fortunately, excess water didn't freeze onto the spheres because it was very easy to overflow this mold.

The silicone Samuelworld Large Cube Tray is structured enough to produce cubes with sharp edges, but flexible enough that they pop out easily.

Specifics

The Large Cube Tray from Samuelworld had the best combination of easily release and neatly shaped cubes. Part of the appeal of large cubes is their appearance. The Samuelworld tray is made of rigid silicone so the edges of the cubes stay sharp even as the water freezes and expands.

The firm silicone is necessary for getting a precise shape, but it does make it harder to release the cubes. I have used this tray regularly for three months; it has held it's shape and has no noticeable odor. I started using the large cubes for iced coffee because they melt slower, keeping my coffee strong for longer.

If you want to take your square ice to the next level, the TrueCubes Clear Ice Tray delivers on its promise: totally clear ice. The clear cubes are completely transparent and have sharp, clean edges, easily the most visually attractive ice I've ever seen. Because of how the system works, you do need 18-22 hours to freeze the whole thing properly. Plus, $50 for an ice cube tray is a big ask.

The OXO tray's silicone lid prevents leaking, allowing you to store it in small or crowded freezers without worry.

Specifics

The OXO was the only truly leakproof best ice cube tray we tested. The lid is a sheet of thin, flexible silicone, with tabs at one end to keep it attached to the plastic base. You smooth down the silicone over the filled tray and it adheres to the plastic so that no water escapes even if you flip the tray upside down (which we did).

The plastic base produced crescent shaped ice cubes that released easily with one or two taps on the bottom of the tray. If you're looking for aesthetically pleasing ice, this tray may not be best for you because our cubes came out irregularly shaped (though still perfectly serviceable).

Though it isn't entirely leakproof, the stable plastic lid of the Target Made By Design Ice Cube Tray gives you the best stacking opportunities of the trays we tested. The frame and lid are plastic, but the bottom is silicone. Instead of twisting and cracking the ice, you can push on the silicone base and pop out the cubes.

Shape: While ice might be the last thing on your mind when preparing a cocktail or a glass of ice water, experts told us that choosing the right size and shape cubes can make your drink taste better or stay colder longer. Joseph Gitter, senior editor at America's Test Kitchen, told us that ice with a lower surface area to volume ratio (i.e., bigger cubes) takes longer to melt, cooling drinks slowly without diluting them. On the flipside, small cubes or crushed ice cool drinks faster, but provide more dilution.

Material: Most of the best ice cube trays are now made out of silicone instead of plastic. The flexible material makes it easier to remove frozen cubes, especially if you have jumbo or spherical ice. Unfortunately, silicone is known to absorb odors from its surroundings. A trip to the dishwasher will sort this out, but if you're extra sensitive to smells and tastes on your ice, try a traditional plastic tray.

Storage: No one wants valuable freezer space taken up by even the best ice cube trays. Trays with lids or plastic frames are easier to stack and store in your freezer.

We consulted two experts on the uses of different ice shapes, how to make clear ice, and how to solve common ice problems. We spoke with Joseph Gitter, senior editor at America's Test Kitchen and recipe developer for How to Cocktail, and Micah Melton, Beverage Director at The Aviary.

I tested 16 ice cube trays, making ice between three and five times in each tray according to the following tests.

Ease of use: The ideal tray is easy to bring to the freezer without spilling water, releases the ice without too much effort, and can be stacked in the freezer. We evaluated each tray based on these qualities.

Performance: We evaluated the appearance and taste of the finished ice. We looked for sharp-edged cubes and smooth spheres.

Odor retention: Silicone is a porous material and, therefore, can absorb scent that then imparts a taste or smell to the ice. We froze coffee in the ice cube trays, emptied and washed them, smelled them, and then froze water in the trays to see if the coffee taste or smell remained. (It's worth noting that all but one of the trays passed this test.)

Leaking: For trays with sealable lids, we flipped unfrozen, full trays upside down to see if water spilled out.

There are two factors that make ice cloudy: the direction the water freezes and impurities or air bubbles in the water.

Most ice cube trays are not insulated, so water freezes from the outside in and from all directions. Safe tap water contains impurities that aren't dangerous to drink, but can impact the flavor of the water and the appearance of the ice. As water freezes, it also absorbs some of the surrounding air. The absorbed air bubbles and the impurities are pushed towards the center of the ice as the outer layer freezes first. The air bubbles and impurities interfere with forming an organized crystal lattice and so the ice appears cloudy, said Gitter.

When making clear ice, you eliminate or limit those bubbles and impurities and focus the direction of freezing. "Essentially the process involves freezing the ice from a single direction versus all directions like a standard freezer," said Melton. To make clear ice at home, first purify your water by boiling it. Then, you can follow Gitter's technique of insulating an ice tray by surrounding it with dish towels and leaving the top exposed so it only freezes from the top down. We detail some other methods of making clear ice here.

Besides the aesthetics, clear ice is less likely to have an odor or taste because it doesn't contain absorbed gases from the surrounding air, according to Melton.

Cleaning instructions vary by product, so we recommend consulting the manufacturer's instructions. All but one of our top picks is dishwasher safe.

Water absorbs air as it freezes, which can impact the flavor. Additionally, silicone is a porous material that can absorb scent.

There are a few methods to deal with this problem. Tovolo recommends soaking its trays for an hour in a 50-50 mixture of white vinegar and water. For trays made wholly out of silicone, the New York Times suggests baking the trays for 20 minutes at 250 degrees F or lower.

The main reason to use large cubes or spheres is to chill alcoholic beverages without diluting them. For example, spheres have a lower surface area to volume ratio than regular ice cubes. "Ice spheres are the worst at making a drink cold, but dilute it the least," said Gitter. This is why large cubes are most ideal for a straight spirit.

However, large ice cubes or spheres aren't perfect for all drinks. Some cocktails are meant to be diluted and slow melting ice can change the intended flavor. Gitter mentioned martinis as an example of this because, traditionally, the gin and vermouth are stirred with regular ice cubes before serving. The stirring action starts the melting process, which chills and dilutes the drink to a palatable flavor. An ice sphere wouldn't melt quickly enough for this purpose, and you'd be left with a too strong and too warm cocktail.

We recommend using large cubes or spheres when serving straight spirits, or when you want to keep a drink cold without changing its flavor and strength.

You can purchase logo and accolade licensing to this story here.Disclosure: Written and researched by the Insider Reviews team. We highlight products and services you might find interesting. If you buy them, we may get a small share of the revenue from the sale from our partners. We may receive products free of charge from manufacturers to test. This does not drive our decision as to whether or not a product is featured or recommended. We operate independently from our advertising team. We welcome your feedback. Email us at [email protected].